Our alumnus of the month for the month of July is a forward hailing from the U.P. who played his rugby in the late 90’s and early 2000’s. Carl Wahl came to the University of Michigan with no rugby experience, and left a true Michigan Rugby man. Former teammates will tell you he is an embodiment of everything that is great about the club, and has taken those traits with him to make a difference on the other side of the globe. Read about Carl below, including some of his fondest memories of his time with the club, and what it meant to him to be a part of Michigan Rugby.
On why and how he joined the club:
I joined UMRFC on the 2nd day of class my freshman year (1994). I’ve forgotten most of my college
years, but I do distinctly remember feeling leaving Calculus 115 feeling like a poor dumb kid from Upper
Michigan who was way out of his league. As I intently studied the grass slinking across Palmer Field, this
big dude grabbed me and said something to the effect that I either needed to, or was going to play rugby,
and that I should come to practice on Thursday. At the time, there didn’t seem to be an element of choice,
so I came by with gym shorts and a jersey that Thursday, where the same guy, one David Perpich, talked
me through the rudiments of the game and got me started. My first game we played a U-Windsor team
that looked and acted like the ’76 Philadelphia Flyers; despite taking a number of boots to the forehead
and forearms, we had a great time and I was hooked.
On what position he played:
I was mostly a tighthead prop, though I moved around in the tight five depending on when need arose. I
loved playing hooker, but the dang ball always went in funny directions when I threw in on line-outs. I
never made it past the 5, though I was fast in an ursine way. Consequently, I was never quite sure what
the back line was up to, or what I should do in the open field, other to get up and get to the ball. It was
around my fourth year I first passed the ball. One last thing I want to add, I am somewhat near-sighted,
and I couldn’t wear glasses or contacts on the field. Somehow the other team managed to kickoff the ball
to me often, but I’d usually field it okay. That first kickoff and hit was always scary, but then the games
was much easier.
On his individual honors:
I really didn’t receive any, the biggest honor for me was in knowing that despite our various economic
backgrounds and questionable athletic skills, there were guys I could and still can count on and who didn’t
care about my clothes, car, money, or who my family was. Looking back though, I might have gotten stick
of the week a few times, notably when in some mistaken fury I put the tackle of my life on Tom Raboine in
the Olde Boys game even though he didn’t have the ball and knocked him out (sorry Tom).
On his favorite memories and teammates:
Oh Lord, all of them. As far as teammates go, on the senior side, some of the most important to me were
Perps (always had your back), Warpig (hardest shoulders), Sam Al-Ebrashi (who drove you hard but
drove himself harder), John Wooley (who cracked my ribs then drove me back from Ferris State), Ed
Spybrook (great teacher of props), Dan Masso (director social mores and morale officer), Coach JR
Hagerman who bore the team through some long low-victory years, Tom Stuhlberg, Rick Fish, Hacksaw,
Dale Tuttle, Elmo Pratt, Jeff Hagen, Dave Webber, and Tony Menyhart (undoubtedly the toughest and at
same time most positive man I have ever met). On the college side, there were many as well, my best
friend/roommate/fellow prop for the whole time Randall “Waddie” Walker, Mike Springs, Lee Gray, Brett
Peck, Nick Kugler, AC “Punisher” Bennet, Scott Salamango, Nick Flagerty, Ryan Gaylor, Mike McCarron,
Rico Harley, Jason Wolff, Kevin Snowden, Mike Livanos, Ryan Lafevre, Crazy-legs Chris Marineau. Brian
Francisco, and on and on, good men to the last.
As for memories, we weren’t a great team and cycled through a lot of guys for much of my UMRFC
career, having a tough time stringing together a club due to the losses. One Michigan league
championship series sticks out, though. Up in Bay City in the Spring of 1998, we went in with a patched-
together unheralded college side on one of the muddiest pitches I’ve ever seen and proceeded to play the
toughest rugby against teams that were likely more talented than we were, but it’s about the size of the
fight in the dog, right? Anyways, we didn’t allow a single try in five games, and lost on a penalty kick to a
CMU team that was on its third game of the series. Despite the loss, I remember feeling like we had
turned a corner with the team. I also remember that playing lock in that mud meant most of my face got
scraped away by the props shorts. That next Monday, fellow Yooper Corey Mather and I went to history
class with faces resembling a Canadian Sunrise and an overcooked pepperoni pizza, sitting down, and
having our fellow classmates leave the aisle. We thought it was an improvement in our looks.
Additionally, there were spring breaks to New Orleans, Daytona, all-over-Florida, etc. and trips around our
great state of Michigan; I went through the Milwaukee interregnum in 1997 where I co-captained
Marquette’s B-side and toured the great state of Wisconsin. It went on more or less like that until I graduated in 1999.
One other weird and pointless anecdote… we took a road trip to play NMU in ’96, and had a bit of fun
along the way because it was an eight or nine hour drive. Since I knew the U.P. best in those pre-cell
phone/email days, I booked us a place in the Christmas Motel in Christmas, Michigan. We were
appropriately merry when we arrived, sang a few songs, etc. The next morning, I think it was John Dine or
some other guy who could draw really well made a Michigan Rugby t-shirt out of a white t-shirt for the
owner’s kid that we all signed and gave to him before heading off to Marquette the next morning. I don’t
know why I remember that other than the kid thought we were about the coolest thing ever in our jerseys
and U-M van.
On his life since Michigan Rugby:
Rugbywise, I joined the Chicago West Side Condors on the advice of Ryan Gaylor and played for another
year up to 2003. After that, except for one OBW in 2009, I’ve played a bit of pick-up here and there, but
nothing serious, which is mostly due to location…
Since a stint in the Peace Corps in 2004, I’ve been living and working in and around Zambia, a Texas-
sized country in southern African that few have heard about as it is one of the friendliest places in
creation. Nowadays I advise and run agricultural projects oriented towards subsistence farmers in
Western Zambia for a non-governmental organization called Concern Worldwide. For anyone who ever
find themselves in Lusaka, Mongu, or Senanga along the beautiful Barotse floodplains, enjoy the kozo ya
luna a buLozi (the peace of the plains) and ask for Kelvin Limota, we’ll go after a few tiger fish, and but
likely catch us some Mosi (the drink-that-thunders).
Some additional stories and memories:
I remember much of the old rugby house at 808 Dewey St., named of course for the venerable admiral
Robert Dewey of Spanish War fame and useful, unintelligible code for telling people where our parties
were going to be at. Like all old Ann Arbor houses, it had a giant vent for the furnace in the middle of the
floor that during parties was the inevitable receptacle of potato chips, Bugles, Ding-dongs, brats, hot dog
buns, etc. The squirrels eventually invaded the place and raised an unholy racket, so someone made the
decision to dump poison in the same vent. The squirrels all perished in every inaccessible nook-and-
cranny, so whenever the heat came on it smelled like slightly decomposing and surely mummified
squirrels. Needless to say, we wore warm coats and doubled up on blankets that fall/winter.
Like most of players from the 80s, 90s, 00s, and 10s, I am indebted to Dave Perpich as he always looked
out for me when I needed work, money, etc. One job we did was tearing down the old DTW in the late
90s for a couple of weeks between 9pm and 4am. One night we ate a 1 a.m. “lunch” at a place near the
airport that I think was called the Rock ‘n Rye; the kind of all-night bar / diner that you could only imagine
being next to DTW. Anyway, Perps bet me that I couldn’t eat their ham and cheese sandwich, which I
took as an affront to my pride and my voracious Yooper appetite. Turned out the sandwich weighed about
5 lbs. or something ridiculous, but my belly matched my eyes and I took it down. The rest of the night was
horrible on the job, but I remember that night in particular as it was the only time I saw Perps momentarily,
but genuinely, poleaxed.
If there’s one thing I could say about the club, it would be the same thing I told Mike Livanos
when he was a freshman or sophomore… the guys I knew from Michigan rugby are some of the
select few that if it ever came down to it, I would want beside me in the foxhole.
6 comments
Skip to comment form
BRAVO! Loved reading about all of the excitement! You didn’t mention any stitches in your head–and I never knew about the ribs!
It was fun to review all of those times you traveled, etc.!
Mom
Enjoyed reading your post.
I graduated with your Dad from good old PHS and NMU. Our grandson, Nate Fisher,now plays UofM Rugby. He too had never played the game but has had great time. Survived the first year with only stiches (at least that’s all he told us about). He’s now reving up for his second year. I hold by the old adage – you don’t have to be crazy to play Rugby.but it sure as helps!
Great work you are doing!
Reg Rye
Hi Reg –
I don’t know why I was reading this this morning, but I’m sure you heard about Dad. If you get a chance, send me an email at carltwahl@hotmail.com.
Great to hear about Nate! Rugby makes the best friends he’ll ever have.
Best,
Carl
Men like Carl are the spirit of UM rugby. Tough and easygoing at the same time. I recall Carl’s first practice. It involved a drill wherein he received a stray elbow from Lou Lafayette, an A-side prop with arms like Popeye. The resul was stitches in Carl’s forehead.
One of my favorite Sooper memories was Carl clearing out the dance floor during bike week in Daytona doing a dance solo to “Radar Love”. Carl was the embodiment of what it means to be a Michigan rugger. An ideal teammate. I could always count on him to be there. Carl, I’d join you in a foxhole without reservation.
A lot of great memories involving sooper yooper and the years at bob dewey. That 98 Michigan cup was a tough pill to swallow for sure, but we never would have made it as far without Carl. Hope all is well!